Saturday, June 21, 2008

Miles From India - A Celebration Of The Music Of Miles Davis (Four Quarters, 2008) *

Plain horror! I have no other words for it.

Brought to you by a host of well-known and lesser known musicians : "The Miles alumni included on the sessions are saxophonists Dave Liebman (1972-74) and Gary Bartz (1970-71), guitarists Mike Stern (1981-84), Pete Cosey (1973-76) and John McLaughlin (1969-72), bassists Ron Carter (1963-69), Michael Henderson (1970-76), Marcus Miller (1981-1984), Benny Rietveld (1987-91), keyboardists Chick Corea (1968-72), Adam Holzman (1985-87) and Robert Irving III (1980- 88), drummers Jimmy Cobb (1958-63), Leon 'Ndugu' Chancler (1971), Lenny White (1969) and Vince Wilburn (1981, 1984-1987) and tabla player Badal Roy (1972-3). The Indian contingent is represented by keyboardist Louiz Banks, drummer Gino Banks, American-born alto saxophonist Rudresh Mahanthappa, sitarist Ravi Chari, Vikku Vinayakram (a charter member of Shakti) on ghatam, V. Selvaganesh (a member of Shakti and Remember Shakti) on khanjira, U. Shrinivas (from Remember Shakti) on electric mandolin, Brij Narain on sarod, Dilshad Khan on sarangi, Sridhar Parthasarathy on mridangam, Taufiq Qureshi and A. Sivamani on percussion, Kala Ramnath on Carnatic violin, Rakesh Chaurasia on flute and Shankar Mahadevan & Sikkil Gurucharan on Indian classical vocals."

... or an exercise in bad taste. Miles must sell, and probably will ... but ... this isn't Miles, this isn't Indian music either. One more record in the "how-to-mistreat-the-Mile-legacy" catalogue, and a nice example of music for which the whole is a lot less than the sum of its parts. Avoid at all cost.

© stef


Dan said...

Ugh, yeah, sounds dreadful... I think they meant well, but usually these tributes end poorly.


Anonymous said...

Least it has a nice cover ;)

Post a Comment

Please note that comments on posts do not appear immediately - unfortunately we must filter for spam and other idiocy.