Click here to [close]

Tuesday, June 3, 2025

Sudeshna Bhattacharya and Mosin Khan Kawa - Mohini (Motvind, 2025)

By Nick Ostrum

Mohini is not what I usually listen to. Stylistically, it sits outside my normal comfort zone of familiarity. Still, I should escape those confines from time to time.  Sudeshna Bhattacharya and Mosin Khan Kawa present such an opportunity. 

Bhattacharya is a master of the nineteen-string sarod. Born in India, she has toured Europe extensively and currently resides in Norway. Kawa is likewise from India but, much as his partner in this duo, has spent the last decade or two in Europe, as a sort of itinerant ambassador of the tabla.

Despite their time especially in Norway and Farnce, Mohini (named after the feminine incarnation of Krishna) is sheer Indian improvisation without clear references to western traditions of free jazz, free improv, be-bop, rock, or classical. That does not make it any “purer,” of course, but it does make it somewhat stylistically foreign, at least to my ears. Still, it is improvisation, and beautiful improvisation at that. It seems Bhattacharya and Kawa are riffing on short melodies and scales to which Bhattacharya frequently returns. In that, it resembles blues and more tightly organized forms of jazz, but in the fact of organization rather than its realization.

That said, I can shake the impression that some of this still sounds familiar. I hear affinities with banjo music and elements that evoke the long, ominous glissando in the Doors’ The End. I hear the endless build (think the barber pole illusion) that likely inspired Ornette Coleman, Don Cherry, the Coltranes, and others to study the music of the subcontinent and adapt them into their own extended, modular pieces. I hear incredible communication between these Bhattacharya and Khan Kawa, mastery of their instruments, expert knowledge of whatever musical tradition they are operating in.

I do not know whether Mohini will shock those with more exposure to this type of music. However, I can say that to me it is thoroughly compelling and surprisingly moving. What is more, it shows yet another side of improvisation and the ways in which structures – a lack of absolute freedom – assist in creating something both novel and timeless. I am not sure this music had to be made in 2025 rather than a generation or two earlier, though the recording is certainly pristine. Although this sounds like Indian classical music, it shreds the virtuosic sterility that the term “classical” sometimes connotes in western circles. Mohini sounds quite vital.

 Seek this one out. Your ears will thank you.

1 comments:

Anonymous said...

Bhattacharya's teacher, Amjad Ali Khan, is one of the most famous & versatile musicians of his generation. He has hundreds of albums. His father Hafiz Ali Khan was also one of the most distinguished musicians of his generation, and a more traditional performer v. AAK who is known for more stylistic liberties. Bhattacharya is in that tradition here, but this is also obviously Hindustani classical music, not something else.