Click here to [close]

Friday, April 14, 2017

Jean-Brice Godet - Lignes De Crêtes (Clean Feed, 2017) ***½

By Derek Stone

Admittedly, I had never heard of Jean-Brice Godet before delving into his newest release for Clean Feed, Lignes De Crêtes. There were, however, a few things about the recording that immediately piqued my interest: first, a quick glance at the album's information page reveals a rather diverse blend of “instruments,” especially when considering that there are only three musicians involved - in charge of clarinets, radio, and dictaphones, for instance, is Godet, while Sylvain Darrifourcq covers drums, percussions, and zither. Second, any album that involves renowned bassist Pascal Niggenkemper is one that, at the very least, warrants close attention. As one of the hardest-working performers in the world of jazz, free or otherwise, he has routinely pumped out music of consistently high quality. Lastly, Godet himself, though not necessarily on my radar before this release, has frequently worked with musicians who are constantly on my radar, like Joëlle Léandre and Anthony Braxton. If the old axiom that “you can tell a lot about a person by the friends they keep” held true, then I was positive that Lignes De Crêtes would be a compelling listen.

With track titles like “No Border,” “No Logo,” “No God,” and “No Fear,” one would expect (and maybe even hope) the pieces themselves to be iconoclastic and even a little unruly - luckily, they often are! The first, “No Border,” opens like the start of some decayed transmission from another world - light swathes of static, tentative feelers from Godet’s clarinet, and ever-so-slight hints of dread woven in by Niggenkemper. As the tension rises, the various slivers of sound begin to coalesce, and recognizable patterns materialize. The first of these patterns is made up of Godet’s serpentine figures, notes that tumble helplessly one after another. The second consists of Darrifourcq’s martial drum-work, almost breathtaking in the way that it leaps out of the swirling stew of abstract textures. Once Niggenkemper’s dense, percussive bass-lines come in, the picture of a somewhat “traditional” free jazz group emerges, and the listener can finally latch on to something concrete. “No Logo” is a brief, creaking sigh before the second long-form piece on the album, “No God.” Compared to the near-alien soundscapes of the opener, “No God” feels like a relatively straightforward bout of music-making - well, aside from the disorienting tape manipulation done by Godet. When the latter finally switches to clarinet, the piece secures itself as one of the most immediate on the entire recording, with Darrifourcq’s elastic rhythms and Niggenkimper’s springy, restless bass-lines offering the perfect support for Godet’s frenzied cries. The final piece, “No Fear,” features Darrifourcq on zither, an instrument utilized here more for its textural possibilities than anything else. As the final ragged breaths of the zither’s strings fade off, so too does any sense that this group has any limits.


Anonymous said...

***1/2 only? That is harsh. Maybe more listening is required.

Dan said...

How is *** 1/2 harsh? That's the same as 7/10. Hardly a "low" rating.

Derek Stone said...

Well, it's a 7/10 which I wouldn't consider to be "harsh" at all. I don't review albums that I don't enjoy.

Anonymous said...

Yeah or 70% which is not a good grade. It is harsh given the effort. But this is just a matter of opinion, no reason to get excited. Besides, this website (that I use very frequently) needs to be more clear about those ratings anyway. To me ***** is a masterpiece, ****1/2 is excellent, **** is good and ***1/2 not so good.

Paul said...

The debate over star ratings is not new to the blog staff. The ratings are subjective of course and for some, 3.5 is a solid rating, while others may see it at the lower end of the scale. The basic issue is that we are a collective and it's difficult to align individual ratings. I'll try to clarify how to best navigate the star-rating on the 'Evaluate' page soon (in top nav area) and hope that it will help some.

Derek Stone said...

Yeah, I think a large part of the problem is the tendency among reviewers (myself included) to ONLY review stuff that we like. That's in contrast to some sites and blogs that review anything that comes their way, good or bad..on sites like those, you're likely to see a wider range of ratings. Here, on the other hand, you might go a week without seeing anything less than a 4-star review. Personally, I would be hesitant to even write about something that I consider less than 3 primary goal on this website is to expose others to stuff that I think is worth listening to. So, while 3.5 might be on the lower end of ratings for this website, it's still within the range of music that I consider "good" or "noteworthy," and music that presently sits at a 3.5 is likely to get higher as the year progresses and I devote more time to it.

Jean-Brice Godet said...


First of all, I've to thank you for listening to this music. This is the most important to me. That's why I'm still publishing records.
Then, personnaly, I care much more about your words than the stars and for that I have to thank you again.
You said at first that you "never heard of Jean-Brice Godet before", well, I can send you some other CDs if you're interested. :-)
and/or please check my website : ;-)

Wish you the best.